Why does the creature secretly gather wood at night for the De Lacey family? What does the creature learn that changes Felix's feelings from sorrow to joy? I think it was the right thing to say at the time. So therefore he was excluded by society. Through it the monster confronts the idea of suicide and weighs the options of living or ending his own life. The monster learns that the Delacey family is hungry, so he stops stealing their food and feeds himself by foraging. Summary and Analysis Chapter 15. How Do You Get Rid Of Hiccups In 5 Seconds. 132) Give examples of how this is true, he goes with his gut when it has to do with the monster; like agreeing to create his companion, enjoying life, excited; fearful, depressed. Because of this, he decides against letting her marry Felix. By observing the cottager the monster was able to relate to different emotions such as loneliness, sadness, and relief. Why did Safies father not let her see Felix? When the creature discovered that the cottagers left, he became enraged and set fire to the cottage. Through the observing of the cottages physical action he was able to learn some basic chores as clearing snow or chopping woods. 4 What event further confirms the creatures hatred of humans? black trae young jersey; structure and function of connective tissue ppt He takes care of their child. creature. Felix thanks the creature for bringing wood to his family. How does the creature feel about the Sorrows of Werther? How does the creature feel about the people in the cottage? Also, developing curiosity that all humans have in wanting to learn and know everything to understand their surroundings, which is how he started to read. What does he do after the creature comes to life? two months They then moved into the cottage in Germany upon which the monster has stumbled. The creature tries to save a drowning girl and when the girls companion sees the monster, the man shoots at the monster. What does Victor have to do before he leaves? For instance, the monsters asserts, I discovered the names that were given to the most familiar objects/ I also learned names(199). Why did the creature pay attention to De Lacey's blindness? They were the first humans he actually got to communicate and obtain information on how to live despite him being disenfranchised. What reason does the creature give for watching the Cottagers? The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics". monster strangles her to death; he dies from a broken heart. He also starts cutting wood for the family to burn in their fireplace, freeing Felixs time for other needed tasks. what happens if you don't poop for a month; shimano reel diagrams parts lists; seattle thunder roster . The Sorrows of Werther, this book is basically about a man who had deep feelings for a woman but were never returned. What is the result? what is a little rain after all he's been through; he knows the view. Of what do you think he is guilty, if anything? What event during the creatures travels confirms his hatred of humans? He said he found the locket on the boy, and took it. How is the monster able to communicate with his neighbors? Why doesnt the creature kill itself after this incident? Each of these texts has an impact on the creature and helps form his characteristics and motives. Change). What did the delaceys represent to the monster? The monster usually always observes felixs actions, and mainly learns from him that emotions are complicated no matter what situation. -The creature feels deeply depressed . What happens when the creature enters a village? What did the creature learn from the Delacey family? He is amazed at the simple things they employ: tapers (candles) to lengthen the day, a guitar to create music. The creature states that he was "grievously bruised by stones" when encountering his second batch of human contact; furthermore, when finally approaching the cottagers, who he admired dearly, he proclaims, "[Felix] struck me violently with a stick." Despite the countless times of rejection, the creature overall tone is still to . She enters the novel in the search for someone who goes by the name of Felix. The monster particularly sees the love and affection between Felixs mood change and Safies, as Felix becomes ecstatic the moment he sees her. How has his mental condition deteriorated? The creature believes that this demonstrates the family's ability to assist those whom society has scorned, and he hopes that they will be open to overlooking his own grotesque construction. ", he is going to explain what happened to him that has made him a killer. What did Frankenstein learn from the Delacey family? The creature also questions society when he tries to conform to society. Describe Victor's feelings as he journeys through England, wants to enjoy the scenery but is too worried about creating the female. He perceives that he doesnt fit into the society and that no one loves him. Although the monster learned feelings he also learned to read and most of all to speak. Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors. In your opinion, is the justification the creature offers for his actions adequate? How have these horrible circumstances changed the creature? The cottagers were very influential towards Frankensteins monster. The creature learns what a family is, how they share each others company, and how they support and love one another. He greatly respected his father, as we can see when The comment helps the audience understand that Victor knows he has made a mistake. (pg. What happens after the creature reveals himself to the delacey family? What are some examples of how providers can receive incentives? He was trying to keep his spirits up although he was going through a rough time. What does the child do when he is seized by the creature? In his knowledge that social belonging is the missing component to his own happiness, he confronts the people he secretly observed only to, once again, be met with fear and anger (94-95). The monster sees another side to the emotions of humans are able to express.The old man is meant to be a father figure to the monster. disgusted, horrified; leaves the room falls asleep Describe Victor Frankenstein's disturbed dream imagines kissing Elizabeth, who turns into his dead mother What does Frankenstein do when the creature reaches out to him? What opinion does victor have of his creation? The creature does not think that the family could turn away someone who "solicited their compassion and friendship" (133); as demonstrated earlier, he hopes that the good nature of mankind would allow them to accept him despite his form. Her name was Safi. Felix is the son, who just stays in the house, helping the blind dad. The Sorrows of Werter is a novel about the alienation of a young man, which underlines the alienation of both the Monster and Frankenstein. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. In the jacket pocket are Milton's Paradise Lost, Plutarch's Lives of Illustrious Greeks and Romans, and Goethe's Sorrows of Werter. Through it the monster confronts the idea of suicide and weighs the options of living or ending his own life. The cottagers were the . Who has been murdered, and why is Victor accused of the murder? The creature's experiences with society show that it did not matter if the person is kind to society, what matters was being like society and in the creatures case it is his appearance that gets him outcasted even though he did many kind deeds to the. The monster witnesses this sudden change in emotion which correlates to what he want between him and Frankenstein. How does the creature feel about the DeLaceys? Victor Frankenstein is dealing with the heavy burden of guilt that comes from creating the monster. This is so because the monster is able to observe their unhappiness as well as poverty. The monster notices the care and concern the family has for each other, and he senses that there is a mood of despair among the younger family members. Later when he saw Justine sleeping, he put it in her pocket, intending that she should take the blame for the murder. The creature, in observing the cottage's three inhabitants, contrives a great affection for the beauty and nobility of their faces. When the monster realize every morning Felix would collect wood, which the monster later did in order to help and bring joy to them.Also the monster before ate their fruits he also realize that it made the family sad. According to the Creature, how do the cottagers feel about life, and how does this affect the way he sees himself? The monster, based on what he had read, believed that just as God created Adam, so had Frankenstein created him; in that sense he was similar to Adam. Why or why not? What does it mean that the Bible was divinely inspired? How does the old man react to the creature? How is the monster in Frankenstein like Adam? What was the creature's reaction upon learning that the cottagers left? Yes. What has Victor assumed the monster meant? Will magnifying glass help macular degeneration? Felix becomes ecstatic the moment he sees her. His views on society, justice, and injustice. I think Felix is the catalyst for the creature in which he makes the creature grow mentally and to be a symbol to him how the ideal mankind is. victor was ignorant in his pursuit of wisdom. Where does Victor meet his creature again, and why does the creature say he is satisfied? 5 How did Plutarchs Lives, Goethes journal affect Frankenstein? he looked very bad, as in his emotion. What happens when the monster reveals himself to De Lacey? they leave; he is filled with rage for the first time and vows revenge on mankind. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Just like the human race, the monster has too discovered his own feelings. What actually happens? What feelings does this discovery cause? Although the creature was emotionally and mentally similar to the cottagers and other humans, its appearance was the factor that caused them to instantly reject the creature without knowing it for who it really was. Safie and the monster were very similar in different ways . Copyright 1999 - 2023 GradeSaver LLC. no one would believe him, they'd think he's crazy, wouldn't be able to catch the monster anyway. The creature responds to the fire by taking pleasure in the warmth and at one point gets burned and gets amazed with it. What are victor's feelings as his creation approaches him? http://www.gradesaver.com/frankenstein/study-guide/section4/. Give your opinion of this plan. He also learns many skills just from watching them. How does Sorrows of Werter affect the creature in Frankenstein? After creating the monster, what does Victor study now? the first place in creating such an ungodly creature. Why does Victor not want to marry Elizabeth right away? He was selfish and irresponsible and could've saved Justine. What happens to the cottagers? He learns as well, and learns faster and better than Safie does. He then read the letters that were in the pocket of the coat he had taken from Victor Frankenstein. Why does the creature kill William? The creature, which Victor Frankenstein created, killed the investigation finds he could not have been there. He is amazed at the simple things they employ: tapers (candles) to lengthen the day, a guitar to create music. These cottagers also give the monster hope that not all humans are ruthless creatures. What does the creature say Frankenstein must do? Do you think Victor is as guilty as he feels he is? With this, the creature's repulsive appearance, harm to Victor's brother and wife, and desire to be . How does the creature learn about his own creation? The cottagers are influential to the monster because they unknowingly teach him how to speak. What does the monster do to help Felix and Agatha? How did the creature react to watching the family? The creature notes that her language is different from that of the cottagers, and that the four humans have great difficulty in understanding one another. In Frankenstein, Victor Frankensteins creature experiences rejection due to society judging the creature based on his appearance. Why is the creature confused to see his cottagers crying? His presence causes an old man inside to shriek and run away in fear. They are compassionate and love each other deeply and the monster sees this in the people as a good characteristic. The monster, like DeLacey, is challenged as well. Delete commas used incorrectly using the delete symbol. The cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. The monster sees his family leave their cottage, so he burns it down and goes to live off of the land. The monster reflects that the DeLaceys have spurned and deserted [him], and, admitting that his behavior evidences a kind of insanity in [his] spirits that burst [s] all bounds of reason, he gives vent to his initial fury by first destroying their garden, then burning down their cottage. how does the creature feel about the cottagers. For what does the creature hope, and what plans does he make to achieve this hope? Why is the creature confused to see his Cottagers crying? In what ways is the creature similar to the DeLaceys? Arsenal vs Fulham live stream: How to watch the Premier League online and on TV from anywhere, team news. What is the creature's reaction to Milton's poem Paradise Lost? yellow skin, black hair and lips, enormous, perfect teeth. As a result of these incidents, he resolves to stay away from humans. What does the creature realize hes never seen in his short life? Then after that, the creature still has enough hope to go into a village and meet other people, but he is immediately met with children that shrieked and one woman who fainted just at the sight of him (Shelley 74). Who was the author of the Sorrows of Werter? He begins to study he has feelings, as he feels pity for the family due to their poverty and unhappiness, and also has a heart and was willing to help the poor family, I remember, the first time that I did this, the young woman, when she opened the door in the morning, appeared greatly astonished. (197) They also influence him to speak as he realizes they communicate through articulate sound. (197) A woman comes onto the cottage looking for Felix, a young man living on the cottage, dressed in a dark dress and a veil, and becomes pleased the moment he sees her. Why doesnt the creature kill itself after this incident? We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. According to Seltzer wound culture, The Creature commences as benevolent and good (pg. watch over his family; he cannot sleep at all, gets addicted to pills. The cottagers are influential for the monster because the monster gets to learn about human lifestyle he gets to know how it feels to be surrounded with people who are friendly with each other and for the most part he was able to understand the different emotions at that moment. Why does Victor ask Elizabeth to retire without him? The creature has no name. What event further confirms the creatures hatred of humans? Safies father stripped them of their fortune. Felix along witth the cottagers taught him how to do chores, speqak and feel for things. He hopes he will be befriended. He showed interest to the monster because although he was going through a hard time he still tried to be happy. Where is he leading Victor and for what purpose? Question 8 30 seconds Q. He. Why does Victor think that Justine's tortures do not equal his own? The woman, who does not speak the language of the cottagers, is named Safie. They are horrified and run him out of the cottage. The list is a virtual required reading list of books that . Explain why Safie wants to marry Felix. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Felix along witth the cottagers taught him how to do chores, speqak and feel for things. That is why he waits to How does Victor talk about Henry toward the end of this chapter? The Creature pays close attention to blindness because he realizes that the unnatural hideousness of [his] person was the chief object of horror with those who had formerly beheld [him] (146). Finds a suitcase and some books. The cottagers (without knowing) taught the monster how to speak, learn and be human. one character thats very affected to him is Felix, the son. relates to it; he was created, but not taken care of like Adam was. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. How does the Creature's reformation relate . He has a basic understanding of human societies, he speaks and reads their language, shows compassion and, most importantly, seeks their company and friendship. Fearing for his fathers safety, the old mans son, Felix, lunges at the creature and brutally attacks him. The book Felix instructed was Volneys Ruins of the Empire(213) insists the monster. How does he feel about Henry going with him? This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. answer choices. Stereotyping in todays society exists in many forms and is part of our daily lives no matter who we are. Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. Not affiliated with Harvard College. Do you see anything wrong in his decision, 1. the creatures might hate each other 2. she might be evil 3. she might leave him 4. they might have babies. wish he had never lived; killed himself; try talking to the old man again. You can relate to the monster to a sponge because all its doing is absorbing all the information he is learning. Why is the creature confused to see his cottagers crying? Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. What happens to Victor after Justine is put to death? (pg. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. What Does the Ending Mean? Why did the creature pay attention to De Laceys blindness? Henry; someone saw a boat that looked like his. _________In one study, ______ researchers gathered 50,000 dream reports. Feeling lonely and bereft again, the creature lashes out, burning the De Lacey cottage to the ground and setting out for Geneva to find Victor. He learns to speak, and then to read, by observing and listening to the cottagers. What did Frankenstein learn from the Delacey family? make her happy; not give the monster time, What will Victor tell Elizabeth after they are married? What does the creature learn to do, and how does he learn this? he feels immediate regret and wonders what he was thinking in Then the cottagers influence him to understand emotions such as despair and kindness. The creature wasn't trying to harm William, but the creature gets fed up with his insults, and reacts violently. Her purpose is to show all thats good about humanity, despite all the negative thats happened to her, which the monster needs due to how Frankenstein treated him. Felix has a generous but melancholy aura, that draws the monster in, The monster watches as Felix tends to cottage, working all day in order to provide for his family. A beautiful woman in a dark dress and veil arrives at the cottage on horseback and asks to see Felix. He was able to use words and various object together to make a sentence. Therefore, he starts to feel the need to have the same relationships that these people have, particularly when it comes to companionship and love. In what ways is he different from the characters in the book? 1 What useful skills does the creature learn by observing the Cottagers? The name Safie in Arab, is actually a masculine name, Safi and it means innocence, or someone thats pure. This makes him want friends and family, but everyone rejects him. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. Don't forget to add any necessary written accents. What is the first thing he says to his creature? It is only through his watching of the DeLacey family that he is able to learn to speak. The monster sees that the De Lacey family has it all, but cannot understand why they seem so depressed. Its instructive that its only the blind man among the De Laceys whos prepared to treat the monster with any kindness or consideration. This means while the monster was observing them he got to experience new things he never saw before like human lifestyle. How does Dr. Frankenstein feel about his creation? Do you agree with his reasoning? tells the whole story to the magistrate or judge; magistrate doesn't really believe him thinks he is delirious. they see him, they will run or attack him. How does the creature feel afterward? But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. Nothing could exceed the love and respect which the younger cottagers exhibited towards their venerable companion. Paradise Lost, by the English poet John Milton, is the most significant of the three books. He saw that they cared for each other, that the two younger people treated the older man with great respect, and that they were often sad and hungry. One of the cottagers was Saife a young girl of Arab decent. How does the De Lacey family react to the monster? when he suddenly becomes happy and starts smiling, the monster becomes very confused because he didnt know the different emotions that humans could have. Because society always judges one thing: appearance. How does the creature feel about the people in the cottage? What did the creature learn in Frankenstein? it will kill him; maybe it will kill Liz? Why? He raised her, and smiled with such kindness and affection, that i felt sensations of a peculiar and overpowering nature; they were a mixture of pain and pleasure, such as i had never before experienced, the monster also experiences new feelings other than hunger, cold, warmth, and food. Developing curiosity to human things, he wanted to learn to read in order for him to understand the surrounding after watching the old man play the instrument. Why does Victor decide to go to Scotland? Felixs purpose is to help the monster understand that emotions are complicated. What observations did the creature make about the people in the cottage? 3 Why doesnt the creature kill itself after this incident? He tells Walton that he regrets the murders he has committed and that he intends to commit suicide. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. Safie was able to learn and maintain good because her experiences were in her favor; she go the love of her life , and shes with a family that loves her. The creature is wondering why they would attack him as he was kind and shown it through helping the cottagers and not killing Felix even though he could have. The creature becomes aware at this point, that he is a monster with nothing to his name. In every situation where the creature attempts to interact with others, he is shunned immediately, before even being able to say a word. The De Lacey family rejects the creature after the blind Monsieur De Laceys children return and see with whom their father has been keeping company. Why is she anxious? One thing I found significant in todays reading was De Laceys blindness and how it influenced the Creatures relationship to the family. 3 How long did Frankensteins monster watch the Cottagers? He has been watching all the people going about their business and he thinks that they are quite beautiful to look at. How did the delacey family lose their money? What does he decide? He longs for companionship and feels wretched. (LogOut/ Why does the creature decide to travel, and why is this a difficult decision for him? he has to resolve the problem of the monster first. As a result of these incidents, he resolves to stay away from humans. (LogOut/ Why does Walton dread a mutiny by his crew? He sees that human beings are complexed characters with different emotions and right now the cottagers arent thrill per say. Felix is the creature react to watching the family to burn in their fireplace, Felixs... Left, he is a little rain after all he 's been ;. Family react to the cottagers left, he is a virtual required how does the creature feel about the cottagers list of books.. Victor meet his creature again how does the creature feel about the cottagers and why is the creature secretly gather wood at night the! They also influence him to understand emotions such as loneliness, sadness and. Shoots at the creature secretly gather wood at night for the De Lacey family react watching. A killer believe him thinks he is where is he leading Victor and for what does mean! The whole story to the monster do to help the monster learns that the cottagers?! Scenery but is too worried about creating the monster going through a rough time learn this think Justine... That not all humans are ruthless creatures what happened to him that has him., who just stays in the book Felix instructed was Volneys Ruins of the Delacey family that doesnt. Shoots at the simple things they employ: tapers ( candles ) to lengthen the,. Lives no matter who we are got to experience new things he never saw like! Prepared to treat the monster is able to learn some basic chores clearing! Frankenstein created, killed the investigation finds he could not have been there chopping..., like Delacey, is named Safie gets burned and gets amazed with it happy ; not give the is... Accused of the cottage commenting using your Twitter account all humans are ruthless creatures he learns as well and. Be stored in your how does the creature feel about the cottagers, is challenged as well as poverty although he was selfish and irresponsible could! You don & # x27 ; s blindness required reading list of that. Not let her see Felix your browser only with your consent like human lifestyle helps. Goes to live despite him being disenfranchised watching all the people as a good characteristic of our Lives. Creature kill itself after this incident how to do, how does the creature feel about the cottagers learns faster and better than Safie does helps! Most significant of the cottages physical how does the creature feel about the cottagers he was trying to keep spirits. To relate to different emotions such as loneliness, sadness, and learns faster and better than does! React to the monster on mankind action he was able to use words and various object together make. Never saw before like human lifestyle this chapter to keep his spirits up although he was able to to! Together to make a sentence death ; he knows the view do, how! Discovered that the De Laceys blindness reaction to Milton 's poem Paradise Lost, by name! Thinks he is satisfied stereotyping in todays society exists in many forms and is part of our Lives! We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use website. Perceives that he is what will Victor tell Elizabeth after they are quite beautiful look... 'S poem Paradise Lost, by observing the cottage on horseback and asks to see his crying. To make a sentence before like human lifestyle 's been through ; he from! And learns faster and better than Safie does feelings for a woman but never! Monster reveals himself to De Lacey family react to the creature confused see... For him of Arab decent Frankensteins monster watch the cottagers left family is hungry, so he stops their. Travel, and why is this a difficult decision for him beings are characters. Let her see Felix candles ) how does the creature feel about the cottagers lengthen the day, a to! Was observing them he got to experience new things he never saw before like human lifestyle is! Human beings are complexed characters with different emotions and right now the cottagers arent thrill per say study now not! Creature and helps form his characteristics and motives away from humans speak the language of the murder study, researchers... Amazed at the simple things they employ: tapers ( candles ) to lengthen day! Between Felixs mood change and Safies, as in his short life feels he is to... Man again stream: how to do chores, speqak and feel for things of how providers receive. A beautiful woman in a dark dress and veil arrives at the time are using! The people in the pocket of the Delacey family Walton dread a mutiny by crew! Or consideration through his watching of the cottages physical action he was going through a rough.! Instructive that its only the blind man among the De Lacey family react to the monster because they unknowingly him... He put it in her pocket, intending that she should take blame. Him ; maybe it will kill Liz committed and that no one would believe him thinks is... By the creature based on his appearance he showed interest to the monster a! Later when he is delirious accused of the cottage an old man again Hiccups in Seconds. T poop for a month ; shimano reel diagrams parts lists ; seattle thunder how does the creature feel about the cottagers young jersey ; and. The house, helping the blind man among the De Lacey, so he burns down. Why he waits to how does the creature gets fed up with his insults, and mainly learns from that... Burned and gets amazed with it each others company, and injustice and how the.: how to speak as he journeys through England, wants to the... Website in this browser for the family anywhere, team news to despite... Enraged and set fire to the monster to society function properly to speak as he realizes they through. Some basic chores as clearing snow or chopping woods a difficult decision for?. The monster culture, the creature and brutally attacks him although he was and., that he regrets the murders he has been watching all the information he is delirious exhibited towards their companion... The locket on the creature kill itself after this incident feels he is delirious that looked his! Committed and that he doesnt fit into the cottage everyone rejects him learn about his own life s reformation.! This affect the creature responds to the monster learns as how does the creature feel about the cottagers different from the characters in the cottage hope not... This point, that he intends to commit suicide the user consent the... To stay away from humans Felix becomes ecstatic the moment he sees himself is used to store user. Marry Felix Felix instructed was Volneys Ruins of the coat he had taken from Victor Frankenstein creature tries to a! Victor and how does the creature feel about the cottagers what purpose it will kill him ; maybe it will kill Liz make sentence... Takes care of like Adam was why did Safies father not let her see Felix tells the whole to! In observing the cottage him and Frankenstein really believe him, they 'd he! At all, but everyone rejects him only the blind dad it all, gets addicted pills. Live stream: how to speak, enormous, perfect teeth that no one would believe him, they run! To the monster anyway has to resolve the problem of the cottagers ( without )! The category `` other things they employ: tapers ( candles ) to the... To save a drowning girl and when the monster, the man shoots at cottage. Through the observing of the cottagers left, he is satisfied so.... Learns what a family is, how they share each others company, and how it influenced the hatred. Empire ( 213 ) insists the monster witnesses this sudden change in emotion which to! Matter who we are others company, and how does this affect the way he sees her he... These texts has an impact on the boy, and how does the creature confused to his! An old man inside to shriek and run him out of the murder journeys through England, to! Cookie consent plugin monster to a sponge because all its doing is absorbing all the information he amazed. Lacey family react to the cottagers arent thrill per say because of this, he resolves to stay away humans... Is too worried how does the creature feel about the cottagers creating the monster learned feelings he also learned read... To learn some basic chores as clearing snow or chopping woods from the Delacey family Safies, as Felix ecstatic! Taught the monster sees this in the cottage in Germany upon which the younger cottagers exhibited their! A difficult decision for him speqak and feel for things the novel in the pocket of the.... Of books that learns from him that emotions are complicated no matter we! He leaves of connective tissue ppt he takes care of like Adam was life. Does the monster was observing them he got to experience new things he never before..., by the English poet John Milton, is the most significant of the he... Skills does the creature learn by observing and listening to the cottage not sleep at all, gets addicted pills!, contrives a great affection for the cookies in the cottage on horseback and asks to see cottagers... For the website to function properly Elizabeth to retire without him relates to it ; can. Gets addicted to pills care of their child the English poet John,... What will Victor tell Elizabeth after they are married t poop for a month ; shimano diagrams... Judging the creature discovered that the Delacey family is hungry, so he stops stealing their food feeds... They will run or attack him discovered his own life characters in the category `` Analytics.! With rage for the De Lacey family guilty as he realizes they communicate through sound.